Bagels-4-U - Hillsborough

Reviews

• Dan M.

  star star star star_border star_border 11 June 2026

  This was part of a small complex.  There were a few tables to sit at and the ordering was done at the counter.  The service was okay as the line moved fairly quick.  They had a number of different options ranging from bagels to sandwiches to baked goods.  The prices were a little steep and there were a lot of add on costs to certain items I noticed.
  
  I had an onion bagel with pork roll, egg, and cheese (Around $6).  The bagel was not very flavorful and was small.  There was a good amount of the pork roll, egg and cheese, which was cooked all appropriately.  It was decent at best.  
  
  Will I go back?  Probably not.

• Vicky S.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 4 June 2026

  Food: three stars
  Service: one star
  Wait time: one star
  Average stars are closer to one, but I gave them the benefit of the doubt.

• Sam W.

  star star star star star_border 22 May 2026

  Bagels 4 U was my second favorite hometown bagel place (I was always partial to Bagel Barn in Montgomery). Having said that, I do think a lot of the ratings here solely regarding service are somewhat unfair.
  
  The place itself is run by two older ladies who primarily speak English as their second language. That generally means that you'll need to be not just methodical with ordering so that you get everything you ask for, but patient so that your order is processed accurately, no matter how long it takes. Shameful that people don't do this.
  
  In fact, I came in on a Sunday, when I expected the place to be zoo-like, only for everything to be moderately busy. I ordered an everything flagel (flat version of a bagel) with low fat scallion cream cheese, and the staff was friendly, asked me several times to ensure that my order was accurate, and quickly fulfilled the request. In return, I got a tasty, flavorful, fresh bagel jam-packed with cream cheese like I asked for.
  
  Lessons learned? Be patient and accommodating to others and they will provide you with what you need, and give criticism where it's due. I will always come back to Bagels 4 U as a result of that.

• Jessica D.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 18 May 2026

  I have felt unwelcome every single time I've come to this place but today took the cake. Walked in 15 minutes before they close and they all started talking about me and my husband in spanish; not knowing I speak spanish. They ignored us for about five minutes before finally one woman nastily informed us that if we wanted anything cooked they wouldn't be making it. They were so unbelievably rude I couldn't believe it. I've gotten bagels from here in the past and while the food is good the service has been consistently bad.

• Erica W.

  star star star star_border star_border 17 May 2026

  I love the bagels here but I would never come here in a rush. The problem is how long it takes to order and get your food. I've waited in line for 30 minutes waiting to order more than once. The person who takes your order also makes your food and there's only 2-3 people ever working at the counter. This place would be great if they could figure out a new system.